LeaderLab
Main Content

The Unique Finances of Your Minister

Part of The Congregational Handbook

By Jan Gartner

William Sinkford preaching from a pulpit, arm raised in an expansive gesture.

Understanding Ministerial Compensation

You’ve probably heard that there are special tax rules for ministers. Most church leaders don’t need to be experts on ministerial compensation, but it’s important to understand the basics of how payroll and taxes for the minister differ from other employees.

Your Minister is an Employee, Not an Independent Contractor

A congregational minister may be full-time or part-time. Called or hired. Solo, lead, associate, or assistant. Regardless, they are an employee. While ministers who simply provide occasional pulpit supply can be classified as independent contractors (and issued a 1099), any minister with ongoing responsibilities is an employee and should receive a W-2, just like other staff.

Here's an important difference: 

Ministers are treated as self-employed for the purposes of Social Security and Medicare. This means that you cannot remit FICA for the minister as you do for other employees. Instead, the minister pays self-employment taxes (SECA) when they do their own quarterly tax filings.* Your minister is only "self-employed" in this single regard; otherwise, they are an employee of your congregation.

Other sources of confusion:

As if this dual tax status weren't complicated enough, there are at least two other sources of confusion:

  1. The minister has a "contract" – their ministerial agreement. Some of your other staff may have employment agreements, as well. Please don't let the fact that someone has a "contract" lead you to believe that they are an independent contractor.
  2. Your congregation may have what's known as a "contract ministry." (See the Transitional Ministry Handbook, page 48, for an overview of Contract Ministry.) Once again, the word "contract" notwithstanding, a contract minister is an employee, not an independent contractor.

Whether a worker is an employee or an independent contractor is a critical legal distinction. If you classify any worker as an independent contractor who should be an employee, you are denying them the opportunity to participate in employee benefit plans – and you could be cited for tax evasion, putting your tax-exempt status at risk.

The resources on our Employee or Independent Contractor? page can help you classify your workers correctly.

Salary and Payroll Resources

The UUA Compensation Program is evolving! We launched Phase I of of our program revisions in early 2020 with the introduction of new Compensation Standards. Please sign up for Compensation and Staffing News and stay informed about upcoming changes.

FICA (Social Security)

Because ministers pay the full 15.3% of salary (including housing) for Social Security/Medicare themselves, rather than splitting the amount with their employer, The UUA Benefit Recommendations include a self-employment tax offset, or "in lieu of FICA," as part of the minister's compensation. For questions, contact Jan Gartner, Compensation and Staffing Practices Manager.


Additional Resources:

 

Clergy Tax Status, Explained

An overview of the special tax status of ministers, the housing allowance and how Social Security and Medicare payments work.

Learn more about Clergy Taxes

Housing Allowance for Ministers

The Ministerial Housing Allowance (also know as the parsonage allowance) enables ministers to exclude some of their salary from certain taxes. For most active and retired ministers, it is their most important tax benefit.

Learn More About the Clergy Housing Allowance

Negotiating an Agreement: Key Considerations for Ministers

Recommendations and reminders are provided in order to support you in having meaningful, fruitful conversations with any congregation you might consider serving. We want to help you maximize your chances of negotiating an offer that you feel good about, with terms that serve you well throughout your ministry.

Have Meaningful Conversations About Agreements

Ministerial Compensation 101

Need an abbreviated version of the materials in this section? Here is a single webpage for folks who don't need to get into the details.

Read a Broad-Brush Look at Ministerial Compensation

Ministerial Compensation: Unraveling the Complexities for Lay Leaders

Jan Gartner and Rev. Richard Nugent explain ministerial compensation, including tax provisions, paycheck components, and benefits. They also share good practices for contracts.

Watch the Webinar on Ministerial Compensation

About the Author

Jan Gartner

Jan is passionate about helping congregations live out their values within their walls!...

For more information contact ocsf@uua.org.