All Recipients
- 2023: No nominations received
- 2022: First Parish in Portland, Unitarian Universalist, in Portland, Maine & Unitarian Universalist Fellowship of La Crosse, Wisconsin
- 2021: No award due to COVID-19
- 2020: No award due to COVID-19
- 2019: The Unitarian Society, A UU Congregation in East Brunswick, NJ
- 2018: No nominations received
- 2017: Foothills Unitarian Church in Fort Collins, CO
- 2016: First Parish in Bedford Unitarian Universalist, MA
- 2015: Bellingham Unitarian Fellowship of Bellingham, WA
- 2014: Unitarian Universalist Church of Akron, OH
- 2013: Unitarian Universalists of Clearwater, FL
- 2012: People's Church in Kalamazoo, MI
- 2011: First Unitarian Universalist Church in Rochester, MN
- 2010: Unitarian Universalist (UU) Church of Tucson, AZ
- 2009: Unitarian Universalist Church of Phoenix, AZ
- 2008: Mount Vernon Unitarian Church in Alexandria, VA
- 2007: Unitarian Church of Baton Rouge, LA
- 2006: Winchester Unitarian Society in Winchester, MA
- 2005: First Parish of Sudbury Unitarian Universalist (UU) of Sudbury, MA
- 2004: Berrien UU Fellowship in St. Joseph, MI
- 2003: Allen Avenue UU Church of Portland, ME
- 2002: UU Congregation of Atlanta, GA
- 2001: Bismarck-Mandan UU Fellowship
- 2000: University UU Church and the Ranier Valley UU Congregation
- 1999: UU Congregation of Laramie, WY