Angela Merkert and Ken Brown
Angela Merkert, congregational consultant, and the Rev. Ken Brown, District
Executive for the Unitarian Universalist Association (UUA) Pacific Southwest District, presented a program designed
to help conference participants understand, plan for, and manage staff
transitions in the church.
They pointed out the importance of evaluating staffing decisions based on
vision and mission. They said, "Don't assume that when a vacancy occurs, you
need to hire for the same position."
They encourage program attendees to think about possibilities for volunteer
staff positions. A person might work for eight to ten hours a week, but be
filling a key role. This individual could be a visitor coordinator, allowing for
ways to better ensure that important connections can be made in congregations.
After six months to a year of testing this model in a mid size church, it may be
almost guaranteed that such a position is incorporated into the budget for the
congregation in the following year.
They said that if a congregation decides to hire a member of the congregation
as a staff person, "You need to have a clear job description and need to have a
lay leader who is working in a structure where the minister is their boss,
meaning that they lose the minister as their pastor…so it take s a unique person
to function successfully in this role. But a number of congregations are
functioning successfully in this way."
Brown clarified that hiring a member of the congregation as staff is never
his first preference, but there are some situations where—if needs are
clarified and reporting relationships are clear—it can work. The Oakland, CA,
Unitarian Universalist (UU) congregation, for instance, has a member employee covenant, outlining both
what you gain and what you lose if you chose to be employed as a member of the
church (Kathy Huff). Merkert and Brown suggested that if members serve as staff,
they report to the minister or the DRE.
Mid size congregations need multiple staffs in order to operate effectively,
they said. Congregations need to have a clear vision for what they wish to
achieve, and they need to be willing to take the risk to put money out to hire
staff. They pointed out that UUs are the most conservative people when it comes
to finances. Evangelicals will take these risks, because they have a clear
vision of where they want to go. UUs tend to insist on seeing the hard figures
for five years out before we are willing to even engage in the conversation
about staffing. Merkert said, "My experience shows me that where the risk is
taken, the money comes."
Staffing for ministry areas is important…and if you staff in those areas,
people in the congregation will experience the growth and accomplishment that
comes from support for things they care about. In a congregation where there had
been an interim MRE, for example, the congregation decided that they wanted a
portion of their ministry team to focus on ministry in the community. Such a
focus comes out of intentional conversations and knowing what areas of ministry
a congregation wants to address in the community as it goes forward.
Personnel issues and how we function around personnel issues is one of the
stickier issues in our congregations. Brown said, "We have to gain clarity about
where responsibility lies. Some congregations put a line item in the budget for
an additional staff person and they say that it's not clear what the person
might do, but they ask for support. And if the plan is put out, the congregation
is continually reminded of the end goals without all the specifics being worked
Staffing needs to be approached as a team effort. "You are better off hiring
people who can work as a team than those who have deep skills in one area but
who can't work in a team model." It is important to examine other positions in
the congregation that you want (they referenced a handout on staffing
models)…because "we tend to think that we don't need people in the role of
worship leader. But your staffing needs to support the people you are serving
during the weekend worship service and other programs, not the membership number
of the church."
Brown reflected on Willow
Creek church's (a mega-church in
Illinois ) leadership development program, and how important it is in nurturing
new leadership. He also noted that theological schools are training people to be
pastors, not administrators. "But we need to see working with people," he said,
"working with the board is spiritual work and we need to embrace it. We need to
pull people into the community and empower them to be part of the ministry
Importance of being a team and of collaboration: Shared leadership in working
in a partnership is critically important. Covenant work with staff teams is also
very important. Understanding staff relationships and accountability, and
knowing the gifts each person brings to a team, can help to shape the ministry
of the congregation. How to develop the collaborative working relationships is
the focus, not a model where everyone works in their silos and makes things
happen on Sundays. We have to hold the vision of the community; not everyone
does all parts, and there may be an ‘upstairs and downstairs,' but we need to
all hold the same vision of why we are doing this and how we will make it
Merkert noted barriers to getting this done as a team:
Book Recommendation: Overcoming the Five Dysfunctions of a Team by
Patrick Lencioni (Jossey-Bass, San Francisco, 2002).
Merkert and Brown emphasized the importance of establishing priorities:
important to remember that you are putting out a plan and taking a step rather
than no step at all; that way, it's less likely that things will devolve into a
turf battle. The congregation's moves have to advance the congregation forward
toward its goal.
Fair compensation is key to the congregation's ultimate success, and such a
principle has to be part of the congregation three to five year plan. This is
also a justice issue, and where better do we challenge ourselves about living
out our values than where we compensate our staff? Me rkert talked about the "
Madison model" for adding a new minister: The congregation advertised for an
assistant minister with a three year contract, knowing that the congregation
might ask the minister if s/he was interested in staying, and the congregation
would be asked if they were interested in calling the minister. That has worked
well, and there is now a strong ministry team of three ministers in that church.
There was a bit lower compensation in the first year, it went up in the second
year, and the third year, the year of call, moved the salaries into the fair
compensation area. Although the process involved asking someone to work, in the
beginning, at a little lower compensation, it was a means to a very positive end
that got this new ministry model established in the church.
The presenters fielded a question on church personnel committees. They said,
"Personnel committees do not hire, fire, or supervise. They develop policies,
help to make sure that fair practices are being used in the congregation and
that people's appraisals are being done, salaries are being adjusted and
benefits accrued, but they are not used for supervising." Brown suggests that a
personnel task force might be used to write policies or consult on different
matters, but that day-to-day matters should be handled among members of the
staff. Having a complete set of policies and job descriptions is essential,
Reported by Deborah Weiner.
For more information contact congservices @ uua.org.
This work is made possible by the generosity of individual donors and congregations.
Please consider making a donation today.
Last updated on Friday, February 24, 2012.
Sidebar Content, Page Navigation
More Ways to Search
Workshop Bibliography (PDF)
Vision Alignment Model for Congregations (PDF)
Congregation Governance Models (PDF)
Changing Worship Styles (PDF)
Qualities of Transformational Congregations (PDF)
Willow Creek Community Church
Donate to Support This Program and the Ongoing Work of the UUA
Read or subscribe to UUA.org Updates for the latest additions to our site.
Learn more about the Beliefs & Principles of Unitarian Universalism, or read our online magazine, UU World, for features on today's Unitarian Universalists. Visit an online UU church, or find a congregation near you.